Many HR departments rely on the drop-off registered letter (Einwurf-Einschreiben) because it supposedly provides proof of receipt. A simple and cost-effective way compared to the courier service. The Federal Labour Court's judgment of yesterday (2 AZR 184/25) shows, based on what we know from the operative part without the reasons: this is exactly what can be dangerous.
The case in one sentence
A dismissal on grounds of illness fails because an invitation to occupational integration management (BEM) was not proven to have been received.
What happened?
▶️ Employer sends BEM invitation via registered post
▶️ Shipment tracking including delivery receipt is available (if this is not available, it has already been the case so far that this is problematic, BAG, judgment of 30 January 2025 to 2 AZR 68/24)
The result in this specific case:
▶️ BEM not demonstrably offered
▶️ less drastic measures not sufficiently set out
▶️ Disproportionate termination → ineffective
Clarification by the Federal Labour Court now
A drop-off registered letter does not provide prima facie evidence of receipt, even if the delivery receipt is available.
▶️ The Hamburg LAG explained in the lower instance that the now missing “peel-off label” increases the error rate in relation to the initial scan of a bar code and therefore an incorrect delivery does not appear so unlikely, especially in the case of several deliveries.
▶️ As a result, the process of drop-off and delivery receipt is no longer sufficient to provide the necessary certainty of actual delivery of the document, which is necessary for prima facie evidence.
Practical reality (and risk)
Standard processes in particular often work like this:
- Drop-off registered letter
- Storage of shipment tracking
- Tick ✅
👉 That's exactly where the problem lies.
My clear recommendation from practice
▶️ personal handover against confirmation of receipt and witnesses (not: managing director.)
▶️ Courier with documentation (keep an eye out when choosing an external courier service, as not all are reliable.)
⚠️ Even if it appears more expensive or complex, the verdict shows that if handled carelessly, it can become much more expensive as a result.
📢 Subject to the reasons for the decision, this was the “death of the registered letter” for documents that must be verifiably delivered as part of the employment relationship.


