Why the certificate starts ahead
The certificate of incapacity for work is the main means of proof the law provides for incapacity due to illness. An employee who submits one has, for the time being, met the burden of presentation. The entitlement to continued remuneration under section 3 of the Continued Remuneration Act then exists for up to six weeks.
A hunch is not enough to challenge it. An employer who stops payment because the timing of a sick note seems inconvenient loses the case and pays in arrears. What is required are concrete, objective circumstances that give rise to serious doubts about the certified illness.
The overall picture as the test
The courts no longer look only at individual irregularities, but at the picture that emerges from several circumstances together. The Federal Labour Court applied this test in its judgment of 15 January 2025 (5 AZR 284/24): an employee had fallen ill abroad in the last week of his holiday, not for the first time. The court held that the evidential value of the certificate was undermined because the pattern had repeated over several years.
Important in practice: a certificate issued abroad carries the same evidential value as a German one. It is undermined not by its origin, but by the circumstances.
Four groups of cases the courts recognise
1. The sick note close to a dismissal
The most common case. An employee resigns and reports sick immediately afterwards, exactly until the end of the notice period. According to settled case law, the evidential value is regularly undermined here.
The same applies the other way round: where the certificate follows a dismissal by the employer and covers the remainder of the employment relationship, you are entitled to ask questions. The cover does not need to match to the day. Minor deviations do not prevent the evidential value from being undermined.
2. The sick note after a difficult meeting
A formal warning, a target-setting meeting, an announced transfer: where a separation is looming and the sick note follows immediately, similar standards apply. What matters is the connection in time and substance, not the content of the meeting.
3. Conspicuous follow-up certificates
The Federal Labour Court distinguishes between the first certificate and follow-up certificates. Even where the first is not challenged, the second or third may be open to challenge. A typical pattern: the incapacity ends exactly with the employment relationship, and the next day the new job begins without any restriction.
4. Questionable formalities
Purely online certificates without a physical examination, backdating by several days, certificates issued straight away for a whole month without regard to the two-week limit, an issue date before the first day of illness, or a practice that has never seen the person. On their own, such points rarely carry the case, but in combination with other indications they do.
What happens once the evidential value is undermined
A common misunderstanding: continued remuneration does not end automatically. At first, only the evidential weight of the certificate is undermined. The burden of presentation and proof then returns to the employee. The employee must now set out in detail which symptoms existed, which restrictions resulted for the specific work and which medical findings were made.
This often succeeds, but not always. It is precisely at this point that proceedings on continued remuneration are decided.
The weak point: the doctor as a witness
To prove the incapacity, the claimant almost always names the treating doctor and releases them from medical confidentiality. What sounds strong in theory often does not hold up under examination.
- No personal knowledge. Not infrequently, the doctor summoned never treated the patient personally, a locum did. The evidence then loses its value.
- No knowledge of the workplace. Incapacity for work is measured against the specific work owed. A doctor who does not know whether someone sits at a desk or lifts loads cannot assess it.
- Only the patient’s account. Where the certificate rests solely on subjective statements without an objective examination, the evidence will as a rule not amount to full proof.
How to prepare the case
- No reflex stop. Do not stop payment every time a sick note arrives at an inconvenient moment. First check whether there are indications that will stand up in court.
- Document promptly. Receipt of the dismissal, content and date of staff meetings, receipt and period of every certificate. What you reconstruct three months later will not convince a court.
- Check the formalities systematically. Issue date, issuing practice, first or follow-up certificate, relation to the notice period.
- Prepare the examination of the witness. A well-founded list of questions for the doctor decides the case more often than the written submissions before it.
Conclusion
The balance has shifted. A medical certificate is no longer a free pass, but it is not a worthless piece of paper either. Cases are decided by indications, documentation and the question of what the treating doctor can actually say in the witness box. Those who keep these three points in view early conduct the proceedings from a different position.

