Federal Labour Court, 20 May 2026, 10 AZR 147/25: drain cleaning inside buildings
A business in Wiesbaden spent at least 65 % of its working time cleaning drains inside buildings. The court held this to be construction work under section 1(2), part II VTV, even though the pipes themselves remain unchanged. The plumbing and heating exemption can apply in principle, but only if the business proves that skilled workers of that trade direct or carry out the work. It had not done so. Part of the claim, around €38,000, had lapsed.
Federal Labour Court, reported February 2025: no tariff interest after deregistration
According to a trade press report of 11 February 2025, the court held that SOKA-BAU cannot charge interest above the statutory rate to a business that has deregistered, because the collective agreement no longer applies to it.
SokaSiG, 2017
After the Federal Labour Court declared several declarations of general applicability invalid in 2016 and 2017, the legislature enacted the Act on Securing the Social Fund Procedures in the Construction Industry (SokaSiG), extending the VTV by statute to all businesses in the sector for the periods concerned. The argument that the declaration of general applicability was invalid no longer succeeds for those periods.
Federal Constitutional Court, 2020
The Federal Constitutional Court declined to hear constitutional complaints against decisions on the social fund procedure, including by order of 10 January 2020 (1 BvR 4/17).
Federal Labour Court, 21 September 2016, 10 ABR 33/15
The court declared several declarations of general applicability of the VTV invalid, including those for 2008 and 2010. Further orders followed in January 2017. Today the decision matters mainly as the reason the SokaSiG exists.
How proceedings against SOKA-BAU work
Most proceedings begin with a payment order from the Labour Court in Wiesbaden or Berlin under the labour court payment order procedure (section 46a of the Labour Courts Act):
- Payment order. The business has one week to lodge an objection. No reasons are required.
- Statement of claim. After the objection, the fund must set out its claim in writing within two weeks.
- Contested proceedings. The court hears the case on the merits: the activities of the business, the share of working time, exemptions and time limits.
- Appeal. An appeal lies to the Regional Labour Court and, subject to conditions, a further appeal on points of law to the Federal Labour Court.
Without an objection, an enforcement order is issued. It can be challenged by filing an objection (Einspruch), again within one week. Foreign businesses should note that service of documents from a German court starts these periods running even if the documents are in German.
What follows from the case law
- Construction work is interpreted broadly
- Exemptions must be proved by the business
- Time limits bite when the fund acts late
- Challenges to the system as a whole rarely succeed. Disputes are decided case by case

